Today is Pioneer Day where I live. There is a grand parade with the theme: “Like, Learn, Love Pioneers”. The celebration is in honor of the Mormon pioneers led by Brigham Young who arrived in the valley in 1847. Today’s post is dedicated to my elementary school teacher Rhea Guild, who grew up in Midway, Utah and came to New England where our paths crossed in my second grade classroom. Her family history included her pioneer Swiss ancestors who first settled in northern Utah. I remember her telling us stories of rain storms that began with enormous hailstones and I believe she introduced my class to today’s book.

Little House on the Prairie by Laura Ingalls Wilder Originally published in 1935, this edition illustrated by Garth Williams c1953. HarperTrophy Edition c1971.
The West That No Longer Exists might be the second title for today’s blog. Laura Ingalls Wilder understood that the world she knew as a child was already gone, and that future generations would not know what it was like to wrest a living from the land the hard way, clearing a place for crops, building your own simple house, keeping your family fed through long winters with no Safeway in sight. It is a bit startling to realize that Mrs. Wilder was still alive when the generation of baby boomers began to be born. Garth Williams met with Laura Ingalls Wilder when he began work on the illustration for the Little House Books.
Mrs. Wilder’s books became controversial in 2018, when the ALSC, a branch of the American Library Association removed her name from the Laura Ingalls Wilder Award, an award for lifetime achievement which was named after her and which was first presented to her in 1954. The ALSC said they were concerned about racist and stereotypical elements in the books. They couldn’t very well ban her books, since ALA sponsors Banned Books Week every fall. Little House on the Prairie is perhaps the worst offender in their eyes, since characters, including young Laura herself said, “The only good Indian is a dead Indian” several times. In another chapter Laura is surprised that the doctor who finds them and saves their lives when the whole family is taken ill is black.
Should you read or allow your children to become acquainted with these books? Is not an effective way to learn about attitudes and thinking of the past to read books written by contemporaries? There are statements in Little House on the Prairie that we would not say today. Today we are also not intending to vacate the former Indian Territories. Children deserve the whole story. Is the Pioneer experience not a part of the American Story?
In re-reading Little House on the Prairie, I found evidence of sympathy for and a will to understand a bit of the lives of the Osage people that were the Ingalls’ neighbors. When some of the settlers fear a massacre because they hear drums and war cries coming from the creek bottoms nearby at night, Pa is told by an Osage leader that his people were against attacking them and the tribes that disagreed were leaving the area. “No matter what Mr. Scott said, Pa did not believe that the only good Indian was a dead Indian.” Yes, Ma feared the Indians, but Pa takes Laura and Mary to see an abandoned Indian camp and shows them how food was cooked and interprets moccasin tracks in the sand. At the end of the book the Ingalls family watch a daylong passage of Osage stream by, heading west. Here again are the author’s words:
“It was dinner-time, and no one thought of dinner. Indian ponies were still going by, carrying bundles of skins and tent-poles and dangling baskets and cooking pots….Then the very last pony went by. But Pa and Ma and Laura and Mary still stayed in the doorway, looking, till that long line of Indians slowly pulled itself over the western edge of the world. And nothing was left but silence and emptiness. All the world seemed very quiet and lonely.” The end of an era was witnessed here and it leaves a quiet feeling of sadness with the reader.
There are many events young readers can appreciate in Little House on the Prairie. What would it feel like to make a dangerous river crossing with no other people along? If the Ingalls’ wagon had foundered nobody would ever have known what happened to them. Mr. Scott narrowly escapes death from gases that formed at the bottom of the well he was digging. Pa is surrounded by wolves while riding home, a bit different from being stuck in traffic today. Jack the valiant dog has a great part to play in the story, don’t want to give his big moment away! Do keep this book on your reading list, and give your readers credit for understanding that they are learning about the past. I think the author had that in mind.

































